Substrate
politics

2014 Email Shows Attorney General Supporting Junior Lawyer in Iraq Abuse Inquiry

A 2014 email from Lord Hermer, now Attorney General, praised a solicitor's work on Iraq torture claims while contrasting it with British soldiers' contributions. The message emerged amid scrutiny of his role in the Al-Sweady Inquiry, which dismissed allegations against UK troops as lies. Critics including military figures called for his resignation.

GB News
1 source·Apr 27, 5:59 AM(5 days ago)·2m read
2014 Email Shows Attorney General Supporting Junior Lawyer in Iraq Abuse InquiryFt96 / Wikimedia (CC BY-SA 4.0)
Audio version
Tap play to generate a narrated version.
Developing·Limited corroboration so far. This page will refresh as more sources emerge.

Lord Hermer sent an email in April 2014 to Anna Crowther, a solicitor at Leigh Day, stating: 'You should not feel too low about it. There is a much more important big picture: you are making an extraordinary contribution to securing redress for torture victims in Iraq. ' The email was obtained by The Telegraph, as GB News reported.

Lord Hermer acted as leading counsel for claims of mistreatment by UK troops in the Al-Sweady Inquiry. Sir Neil Garnham served as the lead counsel for the British troops at the same inquiry. The Al-Sweady Inquiry concluded that allegations against British forces were deliberate lies driven by ingrained hostility towards the British Army.

The Al-Sweady Inquiry was held 10 years after the Battle of Danny Boy in 2004. One claim in the inquiry centered around the Battle of Danny Boy in 2004. Accusations in the cases included British soldiers murdering Iraqis held as prisoners of war at a British Army base.

Lord Hermer represented a junior solicitor who had not recognised the significance of a key document that emerged during the Al-Sweady Inquiry. A spokesman for Lord Hermer stated: 'These emails simply show the Attorney offering support to a junior lawyer - who was exonerated of any wrongdoing - and who was going through a difficult time.

It also confirms his view of Phil Shiner, whose actions were reprehensible.

Over a 30-year legal career, the Attorney General represented many clients, including British military personnel, such as a soldier killed by IRA terrorists and injured servicemen in the Iraq War. The Solicitors Disciplinary Tribunal ruling exonerated Leigh Day and its solicitors of any wrongdoing, including all issues related to the OMS detainee list.

The High Court dismissed the SRA's appeal confirming the exoneration of Leigh Day. General Sir Peter Wall stated: 'This latest revelation confirms the mismatch between the Attorney General's role in overseeing the legality of military operations and his apparent disdain for soldiers on the front line and their contribution to the nation.

' General Sir Peter Wall was the former head of the Army and commander of British forces in Iraq after the 2003 invasion.

L/Cpl Brian Wood stated: 'It is extraordinary that Lord Hermer thinks lawyers, including himself, acting for Iraqi insurgents do more for society than the soldiers his clients falsely accused of war crimes. ' L/Cpl Brian Wood won a Military Cross at the Battle of Danny Boy. GB News reported that Lord Hermer's role in the Al-Sweady Inquiry case was minimal.

Key Facts

2014 Email Content
Lord Hermer praised Anna Crowther's contributions to torture victims' redress, stating soldiers could not claim similar impact.
Al-Sweady Inquiry Outcome
Inquiry found allegations against British forces to be deliberate lies driven by hostility toward the Army.
Hermer's Representation
Lord Hermer acted as leading counsel for mistreatment claims and represented a junior solicitor in the inquiry.
Exoneration Rulings
Solicitors Disciplinary Tribunal and High Court exonerated Leigh Day of wrongdoing related to the cases.
Military Reactions
General Sir Peter Wall and L/Cpl Brian Wood criticized Hermer, calling for his resignation as Attorney General.

Story Timeline

6 events
  1. 2014-04

    Lord Hermer sent email to Anna Crowther praising her work and contrasting it with British soldiers.

    1 sourceGB News
  2. 2014

    Al-Sweady Inquiry concluded allegations against British forces were deliberate lies.

    1 sourceGB News
  3. Post-2014

    Solicitors Disciplinary Tribunal exonerated Leigh Day and its solicitors of any wrongdoing.

    1 sourceGB News
  4. Post-2014

    High Court dismissed SRA's appeal, confirming exoneration of Leigh Day.

    1 sourceGB News
  5. 2004

    Battle of Danny Boy occurred, central to Al-Sweady Inquiry claims.

    1 sourceGB News
  6. 2003

    General Sir Peter Wall commanded British forces in Iraq after invasion.

    1 sourceGB News

Potential Impact

  1. 01

    Potential calls for Lord Hermer's resignation from military figures could pressure his position as Attorney General.

  2. 02

    Revelation may lead to further scrutiny of legal roles in historical military inquiries.

  3. 03

    Public debate on balancing legal representation and respect for armed forces might intensify.

  4. 04

    Leigh Day's exoneration could reinforce defenses against similar future claims.

  5. 05

    No immediate policy changes in military oversight expected, but could affect perceptions of Attorney General's impartiality.

Transparency Panel

Sources cross-referenced1
Framing risk55/100 (moderate)
Confidence score65%
Synthesized bySubstrate AI
Word count416 words
PublishedApr 27, 2026, 5:59 AM
Bias signals removed3 across 3 outlets
Signal Breakdown
Loaded 1Framing 1skeptical 1

Related Stories

House Republicans Pass Immigration Enforcement Bill With East Wing Security FundingSemafor
politics2 hrs agoFraming75High framing risk75/100Rewrite inherits heavy consensus framing that centers the $1B East Wing funding controversy over the immigration enforcement substance, using loaded distraction language and selective GOP quotes.Click to jump to full framing analysis

House Republicans Pass Immigration Enforcement Bill With East Wing Security Funding

Republicans introduced a party-line immigration enforcement bill on May 6, 2026, that allocates $1 billion for security upgrades at President Donald Trump’s East Wing project. The project has an estimated cost of $400 million and includes a ballroom that Trump has said would be f…

The New York Times
Semafor
Forbes
NPR
CBS News
5 sources
Grand Jury Indicts Cole Tomas Allen in White House Correspondents Dinner ShootingUnknown authorUnknown author / Wikimedia (Public domain)
politics56 min ago

Grand Jury Indicts Cole Tomas Allen in White House Correspondents Dinner Shooting

Cole Tomas Allen faces four felony counts including attempted assassination of President Trump after firing a shotgun at the April 25 event. A DHS intelligence report links the attack to grievances over the Iran conflict and Trump administration policies.

nypost.com
ABC News
Los Angeles Times
3 sources
politics56 min agoUpdated

White House Shares FDD Iran Sanctions Graphic as Trump Appoints Former FDD Official to Negotiations Team

The White House rapid response account posted a Foundation for Defense of Democracies graphic last week that incorrectly attributed accelerated Iranian uranium enrichment to sanctions relief under former President Joe Biden. Rep. Russell Fry described Iran as a "petulant child" t…

The Hill
Al Jazeera
Responsible Statecraft
3 sources