Florida Homeowner Tosha Nelson Deactivates Rental Listing After Guest Damages and Financial Losses
Tosha Nelson, a homeowner in Largo, Florida, rented out her property on Airbnb for several years but faced increasing costs and damages from guests. She reported grossing $2,200 monthly against $1,100 in mortgage and insurance expenses, plus additional outlays for replacements and amenities. After incidents including property damage and suspicious guest behavior, Nelson deactivated the listing.
Substrate placeholder — needs reviewChallenges Over time, the homeowner stated she began losing money due to unreimbursed damages and replacements.
Platforms like Airbnb allow claims for stolen or damaged items within 14 days, but some deadlines were missed, requiring out-of-pocket payments for items such as sheets, home fixtures, shampoos, soaps, and beverages. To maintain high ratings, extra amenities were provided, which added to expenses.
Research indicated the property could generate at least $3,000 monthly, but after accounting for all costs, net income fell short.
Damage Incident One Tuesday evening booking led to significant damage when guests held a party, triggering alarms. Upon arrival, a hole in the drywall, a broken door frame, dangling smoke alarms, and a damaged microwave were found. Guests had also discarded usable washclowns, towels, and blankets.
Airbnb reimbursed some amount, but the total loss exceeded assessment costs.
Guest Behavior The subsequent booking involved guests who arrived and immediately checked the mailbox and attempted to enter the shed.
They then complained about a house issue and requested a full refund. Suspicion arose based on their actions, viewed via the front door camera. This incident prompted a review of finances and deactivation of the Airbnb listing.
The property's history includes nearly 20 years of ownership, with rental operations spanning several years until the deactivation. No further details on next steps for the property were reported.
Key Facts
Story Timeline
5 events- After suspicious guest incident
Tosha Nelson deactivates her Airbnb listing following concerns over guest behavior and financial review.
1 sourceNew York Post - Subsequent to party damage
Guests check mailbox and shed, complain about house issue, and request full refund, raising theft suspicions.
1 sourceNew York Post - One Tuesday evening
Guests host party causing $1,200 in damages including drywall hole, broken door, and discarded linens.
1 sourceNew York Post - Several years of rentals
Nelson experiences steady bookings but increasing losses from unreimbursed damages and amenities.
1 sourceNew York Post - June 27, 2025
Nelson closes on new house and lists Largo property, starting with daughter as first tenant.
1 sourceNew York Post
Potential Impact
- 01
Nelson ends short-term rentals, potentially shifting to long-term tenants or sale.
- 02
Higher out-of-pocket repair costs for hosts missing reimbursement windows.
- 03
Increased caution among other Airbnb hosts regarding guest screening and damage claims.
- 04
Potential review of property security features by owners after suspicious incidents.
Transparency Panel
Related Stories
TimeAI Data Center Growth Drove 40 Percent Rise in Related Trade in 2025
Research from the McKinsey Global Institute shows shipments of chips, servers, and networking equipment rose nearly 40 percent last year. The increase accounted for one-third of global trade growth, with U.S. AI-related trade expanding by an estimated $220 billion.
Los Angeles TimesEU Fines Temu €200 Million Over Unsafe Products
The European Commission imposed a €200 million fine on Chinese e-commerce platform Temu for failing to assess risks from illegal goods. The penalty is the second issued under the Digital Services Act.
theyeshivaworld.comEU fines Temu more than $230 million over illegal product sales
The European Commission imposed a €200 million penalty on the Chinese e-commerce platform after finding consumers are very likely to encounter illegal items. Temu has until August 26 to submit a compliance plan or face further penalties.