Substrate
world

Lawsuit Alleges Passenger Lost Both Legs in Boat Propeller Accident

A 22-year-old woman filed suit claiming she lost both legs after a propeller injury during a day trip from a Carnival Cruise. The complaint alleges staff encouraged her to enter the water while intoxicated.

nypost.com
1 source·May 21, 3:24 PM(8 days ago)·1m read
Lawsuit Alleges Passenger Lost Both Legs in Boat Propeller Accidentnypost.com
Audio version
Tap play to generate a narrated version.

A 22-year-old woman filed a lawsuit alleging she lost both legs after a boat propeller injured her during a day excursion from a Carnival Cruise in the Bahamas last May. The complaint states that Hannah Smith was on the cruise with a friend for a graduation trip and paid $79.99 for a Catamaran Ferry outing to Pearl Island Beach organized by the Sun Cay tour group.

According to the filing, staff provided complimentary drinks and marijuana throughout the day. The suit claims her blood alcohol level reached an estimated 0.447. The complaint says that toward the end of the trip Smith entered the water to urinate after staff urged her to do so and the engine had been shut off.

It alleges the captain then started an idling engine, causing the propeller to turn in reverse. The suit states Smith was pulled from the water with her left leg nearly severed and multiple gashes on both legs and pelvis. She lost more than 60 percent of her blood volume.

Smith was taken to a hospital in Nassau and later transferred to Miami. The complaint says dozens of surgeries and blood transfusions failed to save her legs, resulting in amputation of the left leg immediately and the right leg below the knee. The lawsuit names the tour group, Pearl Investment Management Group, boat operator Sun Cay, and Carnival Cruise as defendants.

It alleges Carnival marketed the excursion as a vetted, safe outing for passengers. The Post reached out to Carnival Cruise about the litigation but did not receive an immediate response.

Key Facts

Both legs amputated
After propeller injury during day trip
$79.99 excursion
Catamaran Ferry day trip to Pearl Island Beach
Blood alcohol level
Estimated at 0.447 according to lawsuit

Potential Impact

  1. 01

    Carnival Cruise faces potential liability for marketing the day trip.

  2. 02

    Tour operators may face increased insurance or safety requirements.

Transparency Panel

Sources cross-referenced1
Confidence score65%
Synthesized bySubstrate AI
Word count271 words
PublishedMay 21, 2026, 3:24 PM

Related Stories

WHO Chief Visits DRC as Ebola Death Rate Reaches 30-50%The Guardian
world17 min ago

WHO Chief Visits DRC as Ebola Death Rate Reaches 30-50%

World Health Organization director-general Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus arrived in the Democratic Republic of the Congo to support containment of a new Ebola outbreak. The agency revised the death rate to 30-50% based on confirmed cases and recorded 10 confirmed and 223 suspected d…

SK
The Guardian
2 sources
Greek National Charged in UK With Aiding Iran-Linked Intelligence Servicewesternjournal.com
world17 min ago

Greek National Charged in UK With Aiding Iran-Linked Intelligence Service

A 46-year-old Greek man living in Germany was charged under the UK National Security Act with assisting an intelligence service believed to be Iran by targeting a journalist at Iran International.

Reuters
BBC News
2 sources
Journalists in Gaza to Receive 2026 Golden Pen of Freedom Awardstraitstimes.com
world2 hrs ago

Journalists in Gaza to Receive 2026 Golden Pen of Freedom Award

Three international news agencies will accept the award on behalf of their local staff still reporting from the territory. The World Association of News Publishers cited the journalists' continued coverage under extreme conditions.

Al-Monitor
AF
2 sources