Staffing Shortages and Policy Debates Affect Mental Health Services in UK and US

In the US, programs dispatching mental health workers instead of or alongside police to behavioral crises have expanded to 44 of the 50 largest cities. However, incidents like the March 27 police shooting of Katelyn Hall in Louisville, Kentucky, during a suicidal crisis, highlight limitations in current models.

Hall's case was not eligible for the city's deflection program due to reports of a potential weapon. Louisville promised a co-responder program in a settlement related to the 2020 death of Breonna Taylor, but it has not launched. Mayor Craig Greenberg's office is considering plans for such a model.

Similar demands for expanded crisis intervention followed fatal police shootings in Hartford, Connecticut, and Baltimore County, Maryland, involving individuals in mental health crises. In Baltimore County, Helen Haley called the 988 hotline for her son John Haley, who was in a suicidal crisis, expecting clinicians; police arrived and shot him, leaving him paralyzed.

In New York City, Mayor Zohran Mamdani created an Office of Community Safety to oversee and expand the B-HEARD alternative response program, which has handled over 17,000 requests since 2024. Funding remains a hurdle, with programs in Santa Barbara County, California, and Clive, Iowa, facing potential cutbacks due to grant expirations and state funding shifts.

A Human Rights Watch report argued that police presence in co-responder models can escalate situations. Advocacy groups in San Jose, California, claim insufficient call diversion violates the Americans with Disabilities Act.

The law requires recommendations on evidence-based practices but does not yet mandate implementation. An earlier draft sought to require screenings by the next school year. Critics argue that universal screenings produce high false-positive rates, up to 90% in one study, leading to potential misdiagnoses and unnecessary interventions.

Illinois mandated such screenings for grades three through 12 last year. Supporters view them as preventive, but research shows no proven mental health or academic benefits. The law specifies opt-out rather than opt-in parental consent, placing the burden on parents to refuse.

Surveys indicate fewer than half of parents support depression screenings starting in sixth grade, and many schools administer them without explicit permission.

“The harms of universal screenings for mental disorders far outweigh the benefits." — Chris Evans and Carolyn D. Gorman, City Journal (City Journal, April 24, 2026). Serious mental illnesses affect about 5% of Americans and typically emerge in late teens or early twenties. Opponents say schools lack the expertise for accurate assessments and that struggling students are already identifiable through existing channels.”