Meta Seeks to Limit Mark Zuckerberg's In-Person Testimony in Social Media Lawsuits
Meta has requested that its CEO, Mark Zuckerberg, testify in person only once in upcoming federal multidistrict litigation over social media addiction claims. Plaintiffs argue this would unfairly prejudice their cases. A federal judge is expected to rule soon on the matter.
dailyexcelsior.comMeta, the parent company of Instagram and Facebook, has filed a motion in federal court to restrict in-person testimony by its CEO, Mark Zuckerberg, to a single appearance in a series of lawsuits alleging social media addiction. The lawsuits, consolidated in multidistrict litigation in California, involve more than 2,400 claims from school districts, state attorneys general, and individuals.
These cases aim to streamline into bellwether trials, with the first from Breathitt County School District in Kentucky set for June 12. In the filing, Meta proposed that Zuckerberg testify live once, with subsequent trials using a videotaped recording of that testimony.
Plaintiffs opposed the request, stating it would provide unique protection to Zuckerberg and prejudice thousands of plaintiffs. Previn Warren, co-lead counsel for plaintiffs and an attorney at Motley Rice, stated that Zuckerberg's status should not exempt him from appearing in each trial.
State attorneys general agreed to videotaped testimony for their cases, but Warren continues to advocate for live testimony in school district cases.
“Mr. Zuckerberg’s power, wealth, and status should not privilege his time over that of any other witness," Warren said. A Meta spokesperson stated that repeated testimony would be duplicative, given prior hours of testimony provided.”
Meta recently faced setbacks in related state court cases.
On March 24, a New Mexico jury awarded $375 million against Meta for failing to protect children from sexual exploitation. The next day, a Los Angeles jury found Meta and Google liable for $6 million in damages to plaintiff KGM, who claimed the platforms contributed to her anxiety and depression.
In the Los Angeles case, overseen by California state Judge Carolyn B. Kuhl, Zuckerberg testified in person. Meta had sought to limit questions about his personal fortune, resulting in a ruling allowing inquiries on compensation but prohibiting details on net worth and assets.
The multidistrict litigation addresses allegations that Meta's apps have contributed to a teen mental health crisis. Plaintiffs argue that pre-recorded testimony reduces the value of verdicts and could set precedents for other witnesses. Meta described the push for multiple live testimonies as a public relations tactic by plaintiffs' lawyers.
Key Facts
Story Timeline
5 events- Expected soon
US District Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers is expected to rule on Meta's motion to limit Zuckerberg's in-person testimony.
1 sourceNew York Post - Friday
State attorneys general agreed to let Zuckerberg testify via videotaped deposition.
1 sourceNew York Post - June 12
The first bellwether trial, filed by Breathitt County School District, is scheduled to begin.
1 sourceNew York Post - March 25
A Los Angeles jury found Meta and Google liable for $6 million in damages to plaintiff KGM.
1 sourceNew York Post - March 24
A New Mexico jury awarded $375 million against Meta for failing to protect children.
1 sourceNew York Post
Potential Impact
- 01
A ruling allowing limited testimony could streamline future bellwether trials and reduce burdens on Meta executives.
- 02
Ongoing losses in related cases may lead to higher settlement pressures on Meta.
- 03
Denial of Meta's motion may require Zuckerberg to appear multiple times, increasing litigation costs for the company.
- 04
The decision could set precedents for handling executive testimony in other mass tort cases.
Transparency Panel
Related Stories
Los Angeles TimesEU Fines Temu €200 Million Over Unsafe Products
The European Commission imposed a €200 million fine on Chinese e-commerce platform Temu for failing to assess risks from illegal goods. The penalty is the second issued under the Digital Services Act.
Aggreko to Build Off-Grid Hybrid Plant for Eva Copper Mine
Global energy company Aggreko will construct Australia's largest off-grid renewable hybrid power facility at the Eva Copper Mine in North West Queensland. The 15-year project will supply 72 megawatts of power using solar, battery storage and thermal generation.
theyeshivaworld.comEU fines Temu more than $230 million over illegal product sales
The European Commission imposed a €200 million penalty on the Chinese e-commerce platform after finding consumers are very likely to encounter illegal items. Temu has until August 26 to submit a compliance plan or face further penalties.