Substrate
finance

Researcher Cracks 15-Bit Key on Quantum Hardware, 512 Times Larger Than Prior Record

An independent researcher used public quantum hardware to break a 15-bit elliptic curve key, winning a one-bitcoin prize and marking the largest such demonstration. This development underscores risks to bitcoin's cryptography, with 6.9 million coins exposed to potential future quantum attacks. Bitcoin lags Ethereum in preparing quantum-resistant upgrades, according to recent analyses.

CoinDesk
1 source·Apr 25, 10:00 AM(34 days ago)·3m read
|
Researcher Cracks 15-Bit Key on Quantum Hardware, 512 Times Larger Than Prior RecordSubstrate placeholder — needs review
Audio version
Tap play to generate a narrated version.
Developing·Limited corroboration so far. This page will refresh as more sources emerge.

Independent researcher Giancarlo Lelli broke a 15-bit elliptic curve key on publicly accessible quantum hardware, 512 times larger than the previous public demonstration in September 2025. Lelli won Project Eleven’s one bitcoin Q-Day Prize for the feat.

CoinDesk reported that while this is far from threatening bitcoin’s 256-bit elliptic curve security, it highlights advancing quantum capabilities relevant to cryptocurrencies.

Google's paper this month showed a quantum attack could be run with far fewer resources than previously estimated, in a window that races against bitcoin's own block times. The paper indicated that such attacks could break the cryptography protecting bitcoin wallet ownership.

Quantum computers cannot disrupt bitcoin mining or the blockchain ledger itself, but they could eventually break the cryptography that protects bitcoin wallet ownership.

9 million bitcoin, about one-third of everything ever mined, sits in wallets whose public keys are already permanently visible onchain. This includes Satoshi Nakamoto’s early holdings and any coins spent from since 2021’s Taproot upgrade, which are exposed to future quantum attacks because their public keys are visible on-chain.

Satoshi Nakamoto holds roughly 1 million bitcoin, untouched since the network's early days, in the exposed category.

9 million exposed bitcoin is from the network's first years, stored in an address format that published the public key by default. Any bitcoin wallet that has ever been spent from reveals the key for whatever remains. The 2021 Taproot upgrade activated and expanded the exposure problem by publishing the key protecting remaining bitcoin when spent since activation.

Bitcoin mining uses hashing that quantum computers cannot meaningfully break. The bitcoin ledger and the rule that new bitcoin can only be created through mining would survive a quantum attacker. Blocks would still get produced and the bitcoin chain would keep running despite a quantum attacker.

Bitcoin wallets are protected by math that turns a secret private key into a public address. Turning a secret private key into a public address takes milliseconds. Going from public address back to the private key would take a regular computer longer than the age of the universe.

A quantum algorithm called Shor's collapses the gap between deriving public address from private key and the reverse. Nic Carter wrote on X that 'Elliptic curve cryptography is on the brink of obsolescence,' referring to the math that secures bitcoin wallets.

Carter described Ethereum's approach as 'best in class' and bitcoin's as 'worst in class,' citing developers who 'deny, gaslight, gatekeep, bury heads in sand' rather than engage with the problem.

Ethereum has had a formal quantum-resistant program since 2018. The Ethereum Foundation runs four teams working on the post-quantum migration full-time, with more than ten independent developer groups shipping weekly test networks. Ethereum's plan maps specific upgrades across four upcoming network-wide changes to new math that quantum computers cannot break.

Org, to publish its progress. BIP-360 is a formal proposal from a group of developers and researchers to add new quantum-safe address types that holders could voluntarily migrate to. BitMEX Research proposed a system that would install detection to trigger defensive action if a quantum attack is observed on the network.

Adam Back said at a conference earlier this month that 'Quantum computing still has a lot to prove. ' Back said bitcoin should prepare now with optional upgrades built in advance so the network can migrate when needed.

Key Facts

Quantum exposure in bitcoin
Roughly 6.9 million bitcoin, including Satoshi Nakamoto’s holdings, are exposed to future quantum attacks due to visible public keys.
Recent quantum demonstration
Giancarlo Lelli broke a 15-bit elliptic curve key using public quantum hardware, 512 times larger than prior demonstration.
Ethereum's preparations
Ethereum has four full-time teams and over ten developer groups working on post-quantum migration, with a dedicated website for progress.
Bitcoin proposals
BIP-360 proposes new quantum-safe address types; BitMEX Research suggests a detection system for quantum attacks.

Story Timeline

6 events
  1. 2026-04-25

    Independent researcher Giancarlo Lelli broke a 15-bit elliptic curve key on publicly accessible quantum hardware, winning Project Eleven’s one bitcoin Q-Day Prize.

    1 sourceCoinDesk
  2. 2026-04

    Google's paper showed the quantum attack could be run with far fewer resources than previously estimated.

    1 sourceCoinDesk
  3. 2026-04

    Adam Back stated at a conference that quantum computing still has a lot to prove and bitcoin should prepare with optional upgrades.

    1 sourceCoinDesk
  4. 2025-09

    Previous public demonstration of quantum attack on elliptic curve key occurred.

    1 sourceCoinDesk
  5. 2021

    Taproot upgrade activated, expanding exposure of public keys for spent bitcoin.

    1 sourceCoinDesk
  6. 2018

    Ethereum began its formal quantum-resistant program.

    1 sourceCoinDesk

Potential Impact

  1. 01

    Increased debate among bitcoin developers, possibly leading to delayed but eventual protocol upgrades.

  2. 02

    Potential migration of bitcoin holders to quantum-safe addresses if proposals like BIP-360 gain support.

  3. 03

    Ethereum's lead in quantum resistance may attract more institutional interest compared to bitcoin.

  4. 04

    Heightened awareness of quantum risks could influence cryptocurrency investment strategies.

Transparency Panel

Sources cross-referenced1
Framing risk45/100 (moderate)
Confidence score70%
Synthesized bySubstrate AI
Word count552 words
PublishedApr 25, 2026, 10:00 AM
Bias signals removed3 across 3 outlets
Signal Breakdown
Loaded 1Speculative 1Editorializing 1

Related Stories

SEC Chair Paul Atkins Says Congress Will Pass Crypto Legislationibtimes.com
finance29 min agoDeveloping

SEC Chair Paul Atkins Says Congress Will Pass Crypto Legislation

SEC Chair Paul Atkins stated he is confident Congress will pass crypto market structure legislation. He added that President Trump will sign the bill into law.

WA
BI
2 sources
Iran Says Strait of Hormuz Management Belongs to Iran and Omanasiaone.com
finance29 min agoDeveloping

Iran Says Strait of Hormuz Management Belongs to Iran and Oman

Iran's Foreign Ministry spokesperson stated that control of the Strait of Hormuz must be decided solely by Iran and Oman. The spokesperson also said no agreement has been reached with the United States and that current focus remains on ending the war.

DE
LI
ZE
IN
4 sources
Fed Official Highlights Regulatory Barriers to AI Productivity Gainscnbc.com
finance29 min agoDeveloping

Fed Official Highlights Regulatory Barriers to AI Productivity Gains

A Federal Reserve official stated that productivity growth remains key to economic expansion and that regulatory hurdles are the main obstacle to sustained gains from artificial intelligence.

FI
FI
2 sources