politics
Utah Medical Licensing Board Suspends AI Prescription Renewal Pilot
Utah’s Medical Licensing Board called for the immediate suspension of a pilot program with AI company Doctronic that allows a chatbot to evaluate patients and recommend renewals for nearly 200 chronic condition drugs. The board learned of the program only after launch and warned it placed citizens at risk without proper clinical oversight.
May 10, 5:00 PM·3m read8 sources
FO
+5
National ReviewAudio version
Tap play to generate a narrated version.
Utah’s Medical Licensing Board called for the immediate suspension of a pilot program with the AI company Doctronic late last month. The program lets a chatbot evaluate patients and recommend prescription renewals for nearly 200 chronic condition drugs, with plans to phase out physician review of each case.
The board said it only learned about the pilot after launch and warned that proceeding without proper clinical oversight potentially places Utah citizens at risk.
According to the board, the suspension addresses the absence of established oversight for autonomous AI systems in clinical practice. The action occurred as at least 47 states are considering more than 250 bills governing clinical AI. Those bills address areas including bias audits, payment policy and patient consent.
The Food and Drug Administration’s device-approval process was designed for static products like imaging algorithms.
National projections show shortfalls of tens of thousands of doctors over the next decade, especially in primary care and rural areas. In two years, large language models have advanced from barely passing medical licensing exams to performing comparably to physicians on complex clinical reasoning.
A 2025 prospective study of nearly 40,000 primary care visits in Kenya found that AI-supported clinicians made substantially fewer diagnostic and treatment errors. In the NOHARM trial published in December, doctors did not outperform the strongest large language models on any measured dimension of routine clinical tasks.
State-level rules vary. California bars insurers from using AI to deny coverage based on medical necessity while Colorado mandates bias assessments for high-risk systems. The Utah board’s action occurred before the pilot completed Phase 1, which includes physician review of every prescription.
