Roberts Defends Ohtani Rule After Counsell Criticism

Los Angeles Dodgers manager Dave Roberts addressed criticism of a Major League Baseball rule that benefits two-way player Shohei Ohtani. The rule allows Ohtani, who pitches and hits, to not count against the 13-pitcher roster limit, effectively giving the Dodgers 14 pitchers.

This setup drew complaints from another team manager, Craig Counsell, who highlighted it during a pre-game statement. Counsell stated the rule provides special consideration for Ohtani, noting no other player receives similar treatment. Multiple sources reported Counsell's view that the rule is bizarre and creates different rules for one team.

The criticism arose after a recent game where Ohtani started as pitcher but not as designated hitter.

the Dodgers' 12-3 victory over the Colorado Rockies on April 20, 2026, Roberts defended the rule. He stated that the Dodgers are following MLB guidelines and encouraged other teams to acquire players capable of both pitching and hitting. Roberts emphasized Ohtani's exceptional abilities as the reason for the rule's application.

" — Dave Roberts, April 20, 2026 (USA Today) Roberts added that Ohtani is an exception due to his unique skills. In the game, Ohtani went 1-for-4 with two walks and two runs scored, extending his on-base streak to 52 consecutive games. This performance brings him closer to the franchise record of 58 set by Duke Snider.

The rule for two-way players exempts them from the pitcher limit, a provision that applies specifically to players like Ohtani. Sources indicate this gives the Dodgers a roster advantage, as Counsell pointed out that only one team benefits from it currently.

USA Today reported Counsell's initial complaint before his team's game on April 20. Counsell's comments were made amid preparations for an upcoming series. The series provides an opportunity for direct discussion between the managers. ESPN and NY Post corroborated Counsell's description of the rule as bizarre, with ESPN noting it allows the Dodgers to carry 14 pitchers.

and Rule Implications Ohtani's

dual role has been a point of contention, with Counsell stating there is not another player like him. The Dodgers' win on April 20 highlighted Ohtani's contributions both on the mound and at the plate. Roberts' response underscores the rule's intent to accommodate exceptional talents without bending guidelines unfairly.

The debate surfaced recently, with Counsell's remarks made on April 20 before his team's game. Roberts responded after his team's victory later that night. No changes to the rule were announced in the sources. Stakeholders, including team managers, have expressed views on roster fairness.

The rule remains in place, applied to Ohtani as the primary example. Future games may test how teams adapt to such advantages.