Substrate
politics

Woman Dies After Falling Into Open Manhole on East 52nd Street

Donike Gocaj, 56, fell into an uncovered manhole near Fifth Avenue around 11:20 p.m. Monday and died from scald burns and blunt force trauma. A witness had reported a similar hazard two weeks earlier.

New York Post
2 sources·May 20, 10:56 PM(8 days ago)·1m read
Woman Dies After Falling Into Open Manhole on East 52nd StreetNew York Post
Audio version
Tap play to generate a narrated version.

M. Monday. A witness said Gocaj dropped into the steaming-hot 10-foot-deep hole and screamed "I'm dying" as bystanders tried to reach her. The city medical examiner ruled Wednesday that she died of scald burns with thermal injuries from breathing in hot air or steam, along with blunt force trauma to her torso.

Roland Shearer, an artist and nonprofit founder, told The Post on Wednesday that she spotted a dangerously ajar manhole cover along Fifth Avenue on May 3 while walking from nearby St. Thomas Church. She called 911 to request that the FDNY cover the hole.

Shearer said she was shocked to learn about Gocaj’s death around the corner just weeks later. "I said, ‘Oh my God, this is, in great likelihood, the same cover. Or multiple covers in the same area,’" she said. One day after Shearer and her son Jade Allen spotted the manhole cover, another bystander placed a 311 call to report another skewed or missing lid, sources said.

The caller was transferred to 911, prompting police to respond and put the cover back on.

Shearer’s son, Jade Allen, said the manhole cover stuck partially open at a 45-degree angle. "A lot of people don’t want to fall into a pit to their death," he said. "I just felt bad for her and her family. " Shearer said she reached out to police in Briarcliff Manor, where Gocaj lived, to connect with the family in case they pursue a lawsuit.

Gocaj was a Westchester mother who had stepped out of her parked SUV when the incident occurred.

Key Facts

Donike Gocaj
56-year-old Westchester mother who died after falling into open manhole
May 3 report
Witness called 911 about ajar manhole cover two weeks earlier
10-foot depth
Manhole was steaming hot when Gocaj fell in

Story Timeline

4 events
  1. May 3, 2026

    Rhonda Roland Shearer spotted an ajar manhole cover on Fifth Avenue and called 911.

    1 sourceNew York Post
  2. May 4, 2026

    Another bystander reported a skewed or missing manhole lid via 311, which was transferred to 911.

    1 sourceNew York Post
  3. May 18, 2026 — 11:20 p.m.

    Donike Gocaj fell into an open manhole on East 52nd Street and later died.

    1 sourceNew York Post
  4. May 20, 2026

    The city medical examiner ruled Gocaj died of scald burns, thermal injuries, and blunt force trauma.

    1 sourceNew York Post

Potential Impact

  1. 01

    Gocaj’s family may pursue a lawsuit against the city.

Transparency Panel

Sources cross-referenced2
Confidence score65%
Synthesized bySubstrate AI
Word count272 words
PublishedMay 20, 2026, 10:56 PM
Bias signals removed1 across 1 outlet
Signal Breakdown
Loaded 1

Related Stories

Trump Meets Advisers to Decide on Iran Ceasefire ExtensionBBC News
politics38 min ago

Trump Meets Advisers to Decide on Iran Ceasefire Extension

President Trump said he is holding a Situation Room meeting to make a final decision on a possible deal with Iran. The proposed agreement would extend the ceasefire by 60 days and reopen the Strait of Hormuz.

Al Jazeera
JA
MA
AF
AJ
+6
11 sources
Trump to Decide on Iran Deal in Situation Room Meetingmiddleeasteye.net
politics38 min ago

Trump to Decide on Iran Deal in Situation Room Meeting

President Trump said Friday he is heading into the Situation Room to make a final determination on a potential agreement with Iran. The proposed deal would reopen the Strait of Hormuz without tolls and require destruction of Iran's highly-enriched uranium.

LI
Just the News
CBS News
3 sources
Trump Says U.S. Will Lift Iran Naval Blockade After Nuclear and Hormuz Pledgesrealitytea.com
politics2 hrs agoDeveloping

Trump Says U.S. Will Lift Iran Naval Blockade After Nuclear and Hormuz Pledges

President Trump stated the U.S. will end its naval blockade of Iran once Tehran commits to forgoing nuclear weapons and opens the Strait of Hormuz to unrestricted shipping. The announcement came via Truth Social and a live statement.

FI
LI
MA
3 sources